Thrilling forum

Johan Melle wrote: ↑

19/08/2020, 16:42

I, too, agree about Maculani and Zamperla.

Scarchilli looks a bit wrong to me, but to be honest, I barely know him at all, so I can't really weigh in.

I've argued all along that the Old Gangster isn't him. Doesn't look like him at all to my eyes, but from what I remember, the general consensus was that it's him. Maybe there's sufficient doubt to mark it as an uncertain ID, then...?

So we delete the roles for Maculani and Zamperla then, maybe Old Gangster too since I only made the post from the identifications of others and if neither of you think it is him then it probably isn't.

and maybe put Scarchilli as an uncertain ID, i'll look sometime to see if there are more shots to be got of him from different angles

PeplumParadise wrote: ↑

19/08/2020, 17:42

So we delete the roles for Maculani and Zamperla then, maybe Old Gangster too since I only made the post from the identifications of others and if neither of you think it is him then it probably isn't.

Yes, since there's agreement about Maculani and Zamperla. As for the Old Gangster, I think we should give others a chance to weigh in before we decide.

I don't know Old gangster at the moment, haven't found amovie of him yet, but in my humble opinion, i
don't think it is him in that movie

PeplumParadise wrote: ↑

19/08/2020, 17:42

Johan Melle wrote: ↑

19/08/2020, 16:42

Scarchilli looks a bit wrong to me, but to be honest, I barely know him at all, so I can't really weigh in.

and maybe put Scarchilli as an uncertain ID, i'll look sometime to see if there are more shots to be got of him from different angles

This character does not appear before or after this brief appearance at the bar. Here are some angles as he turns to slap the guy next to him.

Johan Melle wrote: ↑

12/08/2020, 23:25

I have some doubts about four recent additions:

1. I'm pretty sure that the picture of Giovanna Sanfilippo in La lunga cavalcata della vendetta (1972) is not actually her: viewtopic.php?p=27099#p27099

2. Same with the pic of Giuliana Ruffini from the same film: viewtopic.php?p=25452#p27100
I think she's just some look-alike woman

3. Augusta Di Vincenzi in Metti una sera a cena (1969) also seems wrong to me: viewtopic.php?p=27150#p27150
A similar type, but I don't think she's really Augusta

4. And although I'm not an expert on him, there's something about the pic of the White Western Beard in Un uomo dalla pelle dura (1972) that doesn't quite fit too: viewtopic.php?f=14&t=730&start=10#p27138
The nose, for example, looks wrong to me

Opinions?

I didn't mean to ignore 3. and 4. but I'm not familiar with Augusta and still figuring out WWB. You guys agreed on Giovanna so I guess we delete her but Mauro seemed unsure regarding Ruffini? So we wait for Emiliano for the rest and Old Gangster? Maybe @Ciavazzaro could weigh in on the rest?

carlos wrote: ↑

23/08/2020, 19:28

PeplumParadise wrote: ↑

19/08/2020, 17:42

Johan Melle wrote: ↑

19/08/2020, 16:42

Scarchilli looks a bit wrong to me, but to be honest, I barely know him at all, so I can't really weigh in.

and maybe put Scarchilli as an uncertain ID, i'll look sometime to see if there are more shots to be got of him from different angles

This character does not appear before or after this brief appearance at the bar. Here are some angles as he turns to slap the guy next to him.
vlcsnap-2020-08-19-15h44m47s079.jpgvlcsnap-2020-08-19-15h44m56s140.jpgvlcsnap-2020-08-19-15h45m07s218.jpgvlcsnap-2020-08-19-15h45m13s050.jpg

Yes, seeing those other images I agree it's not him, so I'll delete the post

in the filmo, ´Griechische feigen (uncredited) .... Lady in the hotel` is listed twice (plus 1976 and 1977 are mixed up)

carlos wrote: ↑

23/08/2020, 19:38

Johan Melle wrote: ↑

12/08/2020, 23:25

I have some doubts about four recent additions:

1. I'm pretty sure that the picture of Giovanna Sanfilippo in La lunga cavalcata della vendetta (1972) is not actually her: viewtopic.php?p=27099#p27099

2. Same with the pic of Giuliana Ruffini from the same film: viewtopic.php?p=25452#p27100
I think she's just some look-alike woman

3. Augusta Di Vincenzi in Metti una sera a cena (1969) also seems wrong to me: viewtopic.php?p=27150#p27150
A similar type, but I don't think she's really Augusta

4. And although I'm not an expert on him, there's something about the pic of the White Western Beard in Un uomo dalla pelle dura (1972) that doesn't quite fit too: viewtopic.php?f=14&t=730&start=10#p27138
The nose, for example, looks wrong to me

Opinions?

I didn't mean to ignore 3. and 4. but I'm not familiar with Augusta and still figuring out WWB. You guys agreed on Giovanna so I guess we delete her but Mauro seemed unsure regarding Ruffini? So we wait for Emiliano for the rest and Old Gangster? Maybe @Ciavazzaro could weigh in on the rest?

I think it's mostly the three of us that are familiar with Giuliana Ruffini, so I'm not sure we will get too many more opinions about that. Emiliano is fairly busy these days it seems, so if we want him to weigh in, I think we'll have to ask directly in the admin requests topic.

Johan Melle wrote: ↑

12/08/2020, 23:25

I have some doubts about four recent additions:

1. I'm pretty sure that the picture of Giovanna Sanfilippo in La lunga cavalcata della vendetta (1972) is not actually her: viewtopic.php?p=27099#p27099

2. Same with the pic of Giuliana Ruffini from the same film: viewtopic.php?p=25452#p27100
I think she's just some look-alike woman

3. Augusta Di Vincenzi in Metti una sera a cena (1969) also seems wrong to me: viewtopic.php?p=27150#p27150
A similar type, but I don't think she's really Augusta

4. And although I'm not an expert on him, there's something about the pic of the White Western Beard in Un uomo dalla pelle dura (1972) that doesn't quite fit too: viewtopic.php?f=14&t=730&start=10#p27138
The nose, for example, looks wrong to me

Opinions?

I'm not familiar with actors 1-3 but I really do think that is White Western Beard, as far as I can see all the features match, the nose you can't really tell the shape since it's only seen clearly from a frontal view, I think he might only appear a little different since it's the first time he's been seen in glasses and indeed wearing modern clothing. That probably goes without saying since I made the post so of course any other opinions would be welcomed, it can always be marked as an uncertain ID until some more 70's or modern dress roles can be found to confirm or otherwise.

Luciano is credited as one of the ´Segretari di produzione` in `La peccatrice` (1974), for which we have as pic as him playing a priest.