Very important group for generici


Quick identifications
User avatar
Ciavazzaro
Senior
Posts: 3941
Joined: 08.27.18
Location: Italy
Contact:

Very important group for generici

Post by Ciavazzaro » 29/04/2025, 16:34

Hi i did dare to write this because he seems very reliable.
Im checking all his post and for almost every generico/charachter actor he talk about he provided a photo from an older annuario or a publicity still, or a book like the cineguidas we have on the forum with the photo full name adress and a few movies to show the identification.

This is why i found hard to believe he would just invented all the information he got about Lurch.

Plus i absolutely don't want you to think i don't understand you, he have taken also my fotoromanzi pics to use in some of his topics like he took the fotoromanzo pic of Mafalda Amidei i made etc.

But from what i can see unlike imdb he is not using our photos and then saying i made the identification, he uses them without asking permission but again without saying he made the discovery so i think is a little different.

Im not trying to defend him since until two days ago i was not even aware of his existence or of his facebook group :laughing:

But this is why i think it would be worth if any of the people here who have facebook can try to write him and asking him about Lurch, im not absolutely thinking about you, because i fully understand that you would not like to write him, but there are many other users here who did have facebook and in case can do that.

I repeat i know is bad to take photos from us without asking permission, i can feel you, in my case i pay with my own money the fotoromanzi so how i could not understand you ? and same thing with all the other users who pay with their own money books, magazines, bluray etc.

We all do this because this is our passion and not for profit.

But sadly the moment we put something on internet then everyone will take it and there is nothing we can do about it

Just think about all the movies shown in theatres that the next day are already in internet because someone recorded them with a phone, or all the movies with copyright that we can found every day on youtube etc. and the right owners are not able to block them.

I repeat im not defending the guy only im not able to see too much malice or bad intent from him, unlike other people who did stole data from our website because otherwise he would not keep quoting our forum in his discussions with other users (and i repeat im reading all the post and he quote our website very often)

I say that because like i already say we are so few doing this kind of reseach that we should stick together, but is only my very little opinion, and i repeat i don't want to disappoint you because i think you know the great admiration i have for you and the incredible work you are doing !
So i hope im not making you angry by writing my opinion.
Last edited by Ciavazzaro on 29/04/2025, 18:11, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
vecchiaguardia
Moderator
Posts: 925
Joined: 08.31.18
Location: Milano
Contact:

Very important group for generici

Post by vecchiaguardia » 29/04/2025, 17:41

Ciavazzaro wrote:
29/04/2025, 16:34
Hi i did dare to write this because he seems very reliable.
Same impression.

User avatar
PeplumParadise
Moderator
Posts: 37320
Joined: 05.02.19
Location: Spain
Name: Nick
Contact:

Very important group for generici

Post by PeplumParadise » 29/04/2025, 18:34

I agree that it would be good for someone here to at least make an attempt to contact him. I think it would be much better to come from someone Italian as when I had the previous conversation with him some years ago on Facebook it appears that the conversation came to an abrupt end after I said that I was not Italian and used google to translate (the conversation is still in my Facebook chat and presumably his too), plus it appears he has now blocked me from viewing his posts on Facebook, presumably after reading my comments here.

I agree that he does seem reliable, but it is still our policy here to only post identifications for actors when we know how the identifications have been made and are confirmed.

I would be very happy if he wanted to join us here, but he has certainly been aware of our site for many years and I think if he had some interest in joining us he would have done so already (or maybe he is already one of our non-participating members under a different name - who knows?). As already mentioned I think the fact that the site uses English rather than Italian is something that put him off, as one of the things he first asked me was why the site is in English and not Italian.

Post Reply